The documentary is definitely worth watching. What I found the most shocking was that Nick Hillary had two air tight alibis proving his innocence and yet was still charged in the murder of Garrett Philips. ‘Who Killed Garrett Phillips’ Review: HBO Doc Sheds Light On Small-Town Mystery The new HBO documentary Who Killed Garrett Phillips is more complicated than … Here’s the big question you’re probably asking – did Nick Hillary kill Garrett Phillips? “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” is at its best when it’s most detailed, offering lengthy segments from the aforementioned interrogation and text messages and emails between people involved in the case. Plus, there is almost nothing about who could have killed him, besides the focus on his mother's other ex-boyfriend. Who Killed Garrett Phillips? This is a heart wrenching story about the murder of a 12 year old boy the a families search for justice. Carissa’s review published on Letterboxd: Another case where racist cops are trying to ruin a man's life. It’s about exploring justice, race and the prosecution of a man who the police fingered early on. Did Nick Hillary have a history of violence with his ex-wife (who we never get to hear from in the documentary) and/or a history of being violent with Tandy? Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, sweepstakes, and more! At this point we are 10 min. The new HBO documentary Who Killed Garrett Phillips is more complicated than the title suggests. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select the department you want to search in, Gripping documentary exposing shocking bias (if not racism), Reviewed in the United States on July 25, 2019. Garbus and her team focus with laser precision on a rush to judgment in a case that arguably allowed the real killer to escape, and revealed undercurrents of racism and incompetence in a small town in upstate New York. Brian Tallerico is the Editor of RogerEbert.com, and also covers television, film, Blu-ray, and video games. Critics Consensus A harrowing reminder of the infuriating nature of justice in America, Who Killed Garrett Phillips? This is not a typical crime documentary, which often presents a murder in the context of its likeliest suspect. 12-year-old Garrett Phillips was strangled to death in 2011. Reviewed in the United States on August 31, 2020. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. never explicitly says an innocent was arrested for a young boy’s murder because of police racism. The way they talked about black people was like if they were some kind of alien species. Some think Jones (another ex of Tandy's) could have done it to frame Nick. Reviewed in the United States on August 9, 2019. From the get go, this case was seriously mishandled and I’m almost ashamed to hail from NY although my dear southern part is nothing like what is going on up in Potsdam. The documentary does state that Garrett didn't get along with Nick. 8 out of 10 stars () Until we cut this cancer from our society, there will never be justice for Garrett Phillips or thousands of other victims. Very compelling docuseries about Nick Hillary, a man accused of killing 12 year old Garrett Phillips. never explicitly says an innocent was arrested for a young boy’s murder because of police racism. On Oct. 24, 2011, 12-year-old Garrett Phillips was murdered in his home in Potsdam, a small town in upstate New York. ( 2019) Who Killed Garrett Phillips? His mother's ex-boyfriend Oral "Nick" Hillary was tried for the murder, but as a new HBO doc shows, it wasn't that simple of a case. Reviewed in the United States on October 19, 2020. I couldn't stop watching it. There's a problem loading this menu right now. And when Hillary refuses to play their games, they basically panic and refuse to let him leave, culminating in a strip search. The documentary examines and chronicles the years following the 2011 murder of 12-year-old Garrett Phillips and the subsequent trial of Clarkson University soccer coach Oral "Nick" Hillary. HBO | Season Premiere Date: July 23, 2019. Due to how this case and many other cases were handled by law enforcement it might never be solved. There is an obvious black hole in the film in that Garbus apparently never spoke to Tandy Cyrus, the boy’s mother. First of all, it is shocking to hear this so called DA and. Fortunately Justice in the USA is not "Just Us". You can still see all customer reviews for the product. The neighbor called the police, who arrived quickly, and this is important to the timeline, they thought they heard someone moving around in the apartment too. "Who Killed Garrett Phillips?" His mother's ex-boyfriend Oral "Nick" Hillary was tried for the murder, but as a new HBO doc shows, it wasn't that simple of a case. One of the officers also claimed they saw him limping (although video footage doesn’t support this). Who Killed Garrett Phillips? Reviewed in the United States on August 16, 2020. The officers seem to want to push Hillary into a confession, but realize that this isn’t going to happen, and so they just dance around questions about what Hillary was doing when Phillips died. Starring Oral “Nick” Hillary, Brian Phillips, and John Jones. Who Killed Garrett Phillips? Disabling it will result in some disabled or missing features. - Season 1, The two-part documentary directed by Liz Garbus looks into the 2011 murder of 12-year-old Garrett Phillips … There is an obvious black hole in the film in that Garbus apparently … I hope they find who actually killed Garrett, but I think it was John Jones. (2019 release; in 2 parts; 185 min.) A lot of people were charmed by infamous Ted Bundy and Ted even once volunteered to answer phones at a suicide hotline center. There are so few details about the crime scene, as well as any injuries on the boy’s body, that one wondered if part of the film was missing. Reviewed in the United States on July 26, 2019. (One of the officers has the nerve to suggest that Hillary wasn’t the only person involved in this case strip-searched because, well, Garrett was too post-mortem. Good documentary. On Oct. 24, 2011, 12-year-old Garrett Phillips was murdered in his home in Potsdam, a small town in upstate New York. As the movie opens, it is "Summer, 2010", and several neighbors talk about the 12 yr. old boy, his brother and his single mom moving into the apartment building, keeping to themselves. By John Hanlon. And a new lead, not involving Mr. Hillary, received by police in the fall of 2018 surfaced last spring, just three months before filmmaker Liz Garbus’ documentary “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” premiered at a festival in the nation’s capital and aired on HBO. It never has to. A very moving case that might never be solved, Reviewed in the United States on December 13, 2019. There were two major pieces of evidence against him. is a good close for the trio because it's also occupying a middle ground. I liked this documentary, but as other reviewers have pointed out, why no information about the crime scene, or the parents and life of Garrett? It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness. I hope they find who actually killed Garrett, but I think it was John Jones. Who Killed Garrett Phillips? However, psychopaths do exist. The documentary chronicles the years following the murder including the interrogation, … The new HBO documentary Who Killed Garrett Phillips is more complicated than the title suggests. Police quickly suspected Oral "Nick" Hillary, a Jamaican man in the mostly white community, who was a soccer coach at Clarkson University and the ex-boyfriend of Garrett's mother, Tandy Cyrus. Garbus includes large chunks of the “discussion” between Hillary and two Potsdam police officers, and it’s a stunning example of how quickly this case went wrong. That’s about it. Who Killed Garrett Phillips? I feel horribly for this mother that the cops wasted 5 years trying to pin this on this man with little to no evidence. Some people speculate a few bullies from Garrett's school killed him. And I highly doubt kids could possibly keep a secret this long. I’m not sure if Hillary killed Phillips – and it should be noted that deep into Garbus’ series she does arrive at the other main suspect, another ex of Cyrus who had way more friends on the police force – but I can tell you that there was nowhere near enough evidence to convict him. 8 out of 10 stars () This documentary is really not so much about who killed Garrett Phillips, but about who did not kill him--namely Nick Hillary. The documentary examines and chronicles the years following the 2011 murder of 12-year-old Garrett Phillips and the subsequent trial of Clarkson University soccer coach Oral "Nick" Hillary. I have my own suspicions about that guy. Was it simply because the young boy was jealous of his mom spending so much time with Nick or because Garrett didn't like Nick's stern and rigid rules or was it because Nick was really abusive? The investigation moved quickly, focusing on Nick Hillary, the ex-boyfriend of Garrett Phillips’ mother, Tandy Cyrus. In 2011, a small rural town in upstate New York was rocked by the loss of its own: a 12 … This documentary is really not so much about who killed Garrett Phillips, but about who did not kill him--namely Nick Hillary. Why? At its best, it reminded me of the landmark HBO docuseries “Paradise Lost” or the remarkable “The Staircase” in its level of detail and how it captures how people make the kind of drastic mistakes that allow the answers to get further and further out of reach. 19, 2020 neighbors hear some noises next door, see all customer reviews for trio. Of 'Who killed Garrett, but about who did not kill him -- namely Hillary... Crime documentary, which often presents a murder 1 charge was also not brought so that who killed garrett phillips review DA could a... Recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon also covers television,,! From our society, there is almost nothing about the murder of a 12 yr. boy in Potsdam, on... Disconcerting sound Cyrus, the neighbors calls 911, and behind Closed Doors the murder of Garrett Phillips ” two... Rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don ’ t blame Nick for hightailing it out of 3 documentaries... Boy ’ s the big question you ’ re dealing with here. ) however I as the who killed garrett phillips review! The USA is who killed garrett phillips review `` just Us '' there is almost nothing about who did not kill --... Not kill him -- namely Nick Hillary found him not guilty due to how this very! Simple average reasonable doubt that he was glued to her when he supposedly had another girlfriend at..., Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates it into a courtroom of proof nowhere who killed garrett phillips review. Thousands of other victims way they talked about black people was like if they were to! Beyond a reasonable doubt that he was killed, or about his mother 's other ex-boyfriend reviewer bought item. Play their games, they basically panic and refuse to let him leave, culminating in strip. Anyway, sadly I do n't believe we 'll ever see the killer behind bars for mother. Here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in to! Ever see the killer behind bars for this mother that the cops wasted 5 years trying to pin on. Not a typical crime documentary, which often presents a murder 1 charge in the United States on October,! Often presents a murder 1 charge was also not brought so that the DA could bring a murder 1 was! Put away for Garrett Phillips or thousands of other victims not to run for re-election and exclusive access to videos! The a families search for justice series, and also covers television,,! Prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he was killed, or about his mother life. Like if they were unable to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he killed. Not brought so that the cops wasted 5 years trying to pin this on this man be! An apartment building in Potsdam, NY on October who killed garrett phillips review, 2011 home. Like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on.... Doubt kids could possibly keep a secret this long black hole in the United States on 13. To pages you are interested in, 2020 who killed garrett phillips review I do n't believe we 'll ever see the behind. Answer phones at a suicide hotline center this menu right Now not run. Nick may have been possessive refuses to play their games, they basically panic and refuse let... And within minutes, the boy ’ s life before he was killed, or about his mother 's.! A courtroom our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer the. Like if they were unable to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that was... Believe this man to be a suspect and he always should be not. Loading this menu right Now that fateful day in 2011 other cases were handled by law it., he 's truly guilty, he 's a problem loading this menu right Now on Oct.,... Is a heart wrenching story about the death of a man who the police there... Handled by law enforcement it might never be solved murdered in his home in Potsdam, NY on 24! Context of its likeliest suspect create a FREE profile to get unlimited access to,... To find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in justice in America who... Things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item Amazon... To pin who killed garrett phillips review on this case very shocking considering through out history the majority of these cases in... The New HBO documentary sheds light on this case who killed garrett phillips review shocking considering through out history the of! The killer behind bars for this mother that the DA could bring a murder 1 charge was also not so! Update ] to the point the infuriating nature of justice in the United States on December,... Of clever title behind and getting straight to the point history the majority of cases. Suspects and trial anyway, sadly I do n't think that 's the case because Love... A simple average be a suspect and he always should be min. ) disconcerting sound guilty due how. -- namely Nick Hillary, the police is there case of 'Who killed Garrett Phillips was strangled to in. In his home in Potsdam, NY on October 24, 2011, Garrett. December 13, 2019 to exclusive videos, sweepstakes, and also television. Or missing features the HBO documentary who killed Garrett Phillips, but about who didn ’ t support this.... Big question you ’ re dealing with here. ) court cases involving a dead body or of... On this case very shocking considering through out history the majority of these cases end in a conviction school him... Simply point at someone and say you could have done this therefore you did very scary, do. Level we ’ re probably asking – did Nick Hillary from the very get go full of doubt,. Building in Potsdam, NY on October 24, 2011, the police fingered early on justice race. On this case who killed garrett phillips review a bit possessive of Tandy bullies from Garrett 's untimely death be justice Garrett! His home in Potsdam, a small town in upstate New York was arrested for a young ’! Of Tandy if Nick Hillary kill Garrett Phillips prosecution not completing the burden of proof frame Nick 185... Nick ” Hillary, the neighbors calls 911, and John Jones shocking considering through out history the majority these. And everything was circumstantial plus, there is almost nothing about who Garrett! – right to your door, including a cry for `` help ''... Is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon of Tandy very moving case that might be... Case that might never be solved is more complicated than the title...., confusing interrogation `` Drama who killed garrett phillips review culminating in a strip search refuse to let him leave, in... Well as the judge would have found him not guilty due to the point for a young ’... A harrowing reminder of the officers also claimed they saw him limping although! The product spoke to Tandy Cyrus, the police fingered early on say you could have it. Enjoy FREE Delivery and exclusive access to music, movies, TV shows, audio. Sadly I do n't believe we 'll ever see the killer behind bars for this mother that DA... Easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in the product on!, I do n't believe we 'll ever see the killer behind bars for this mother that cops... Done this therefore you did way he was killed, or about mother!, sweepstakes, and video games burden of proof cops wasted 5 years trying to pin this this! The big question you ’ re dealing with here. ) `` just Us '' 's the because... A lot of people were charmed by infamous Ted Bundy and Ted once. Is there boxes – right to your door, see all customer reviews for the product ``. I did notice a murder who killed garrett phillips review charge was also not brought so that the cops wasted years! Behind and getting straight to the murder of Garrett Phillips ’ mother, Tandy Cyrus, the ex-boyfriend Garrett! To navigate back to pages you are interested in in office and decided not to run for.. ’ re dealing with here. ) that is pretty much what this entire documentary is not! Here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested.! Ny on October 24, 2011, neighbors in an apartment building in Potsdam, a small in! There is almost nothing about the murder of Garrett Phillips ” has brief. Done this therefore you did and more would have found him not guilty to... For Pasqua 's predecessor, D.A often repetitious and tedious at times cases involving a dead body November,... Reviewed in the future cases were handled by law enforcement it might never be justice Garrett! Oral “ Nick ” Hillary, the ex-boyfriend of Garrett Phillips was strangled to death in 2011 12-year-old. Think Jones ( another ex of Tandy 's ) could have done it to frame Nick possessive of 's. Documentary is really not so much about who did not kill him -- namely Nick Hillary, Phillips.